🔍 Read the full analysis: One Humanist Won An Exemption From AI. Does The Law Go Further? on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get business pricing on office and shipping supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
TL;DR
The University of Kentucky approved research administrator David Durman’s request to be excused from personally using AI tools at work, citing his Humanist beliefs. The decision applies to his job and is not a court ruling; the boundaries of the accommodation and how other employers would respond remain case-specific.
The University of Kentucky approved research administrator David Durman’s request to be excused from personally using artificial-intelligence tools at work, accepting his Humanist beliefs as the basis for a religious accommodation. The September 25 decision is an individual workplace accommodation, not a court ruling, and does not establish what other employers must do in similar cases.
Durman helps researchers apply for grants. In an August 24 letter to the university’s Office of Equal Opportunity, he asked to be exempt from personally using AI or large language model tools, including automated transcription, note-taking and decision systems. The American Humanist Association (AHA) helped him prepare the request. Durman offered to take and share meeting notes himself, according to the letter published by the AHA.
The request followed a July 31 department meeting where Microsoft Teams Copilot was promoted for meeting notes, according to Durman’s letter. He also cited suggested use of commercial tools such as ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini, as well as internal AI systems in development. He was not yet required to use AI, TechCrunch reported, but sought an accommodation in case recommendations became a mandate.
The university approved the request after a meeting with Durman and AHA staff attorney Alexandria Huiskens in mid-September. The AHA said the office found the accommodation posed “no undue burden on his department.” A university spokesperson told TechCrunch that an accommodation could be provided while Durman continued performing the essential functions of his job.
Infographic 01 · University of Kentucky · 2026
One letter, one meeting, one narrow exemption.
A Humanist research administrator asked not to use AI himself. His employer, which rolled out Copilot campus-wide, said yes.
- 31 Jul 2026Copilot promoted for meeting notesAt a department meeting, per Durman’s letter. Chatbots suggested, internal AI tools in development.
- 24 AugTwo-page letter to the Office of Equal OpportunityRequest under Title VII, drafted with the American Humanist Association. “Using AI or LLM tools is not an essential function of my position.”
- Mid-SepOne meetingDurman and the AHA’s staff attorney meet university officials. “A very collegial meeting.”
- 25 SepApproved“No undue burden on his department,” per the AHA. No lawsuit, no court, no precedent.
- 26 to 29 OctMade publicAHA, Religion News Service, then TechCrunch.
Excused
- Personal use of AI or LLM tools to complete his own tasks
- AI note-taking: he takes and shares his own notes
Still expected
- Taking part in meetings that use AI
- Submitting materials through systems that use AI
- Same duties; colleagues keep using AI
- May be reviewed “as technology and job responsibilities evolve”
“David is excused from personal use of AI to complete his tasks.”University approval letter, as quoted by Religion News Service. The letter itself is not public.
Sources: Durman letter, 24 Aug 2026; AHA press release, 26 Oct 2026; RNS, 26 Oct 2026 (quotes the approval letter); TechCrunch, 29 Oct 2026 (university statement). Timeline and layout: Thorsten Meyer.
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
A Personal Exemption, Not an AI Ban
The decision applies a workplace accommodation process to an employee’s request based on a stated belief about using new technology. It does not give employees a general right to refuse AI, nor does it prevent the university from using AI elsewhere. The scope is Durman’s personal use of the tools, not a ban on their use by coworkers or the institution.
The decision may be relevant to workers whose employers encourage or require AI use, but outcomes will depend on the employee’s beliefs and duties, and on whether an employer can accommodate the request without undue hardship. Durman said, “I believe that our capacity to think and reason for ourselves is worth protecting,” in a statement cited by the AHA. The statement describes his concern; it does not determine how another request would be assessed.
The university said Durman could continue performing the essential functions of his job with the accommodation and that it would not impose an undue burden on his department. The decision concerns his workplace arrangement and does not establish how other employers must handle similar requests.
Popular right now

Dyson Cyclone V10 Origin Cordless Vacuum

Bose QuietComfort Wireless Noise-Cancelling Headphones, Twilight Blue

Vitamix VX1 Professional-Grade Blender, 64 oz, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How Workplace Religious Accommodation Applies
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act requires covered employers to accommodate an employee’s sincerely held religious beliefs when they conflict with a work requirement, unless doing so would cause undue hardship. Federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission guidance includes certain moral or ethical beliefs held with the strength of traditional religious views; belief in a god is not required. The law does not treat ordinary personal preferences or political views as religious beliefs simply because someone holds them strongly.
In Groff v. DeJoy in 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court clarified that an employer claiming undue hardship must show substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business. Employers must consider the circumstances and possible alternatives. The legal standard provides context for Durman’s request, but the university’s approval itself does not test or settle the law in court.
Business Insider reported in June that Erin Maus, a Unitarian Universalist software engineer in North Carolina, received an exemption from using AI in May. The AHA describes Durman as the first Humanist to obtain one; that “first” characterization is the organization’s claim, not a court finding. Microsoft separately said the University of Kentucky had achieved “100 percent deployment” of Microsoft 365 Copilot.
“I believe that our capacity to think and reason for ourselves is worth protecting.”
— David Durman, in a statement cited by the American Humanist Association
Limits of the Approved Accommodation
The full day-to-day boundaries of the exemption are not clear from the public accounts. Religion News Service reported that, under the approval letter, Durman may still need to attend meetings where AI is used and submit materials through systems that include AI. The accommodation concerns his personal use of AI, but the precise treatment of every workflow has not been described publicly.
The university said accommodations may be reviewed as jobs change. It is also not known whether the university will face a future dispute over the decision, or how another employer would assess a similar request. The available reporting does not establish that all Humanist beliefs, objections to AI, or requests to avoid particular software qualify for accommodation.
No court has ruled on Durman’s request, and the university’s decision does not create a binding precedent. The AHA’s description of him as the first Humanist to receive such an exemption should be understood as the organization’s claim. The sources do not provide a complete account of all comparable workplace requests nationwide.
How the Exemption May Be Reviewed
Durman can continue his work under the accommodation approved on September 25. The university may revisit the arrangement if his responsibilities change, according to the reported terms of the approval. No further review date, appeal or court proceeding has been announced in the source material.
Employees considering a similar request would need to raise it through their employer’s accommodation process; the Kentucky outcome does not guarantee approval elsewhere. Employers would assess the particular job, the belief asserted and possible adjustments under applicable law. Any developments would depend on changes to Durman’s duties or the university’s AI requirements, or on other employees seeking comparable accommodations.
Key Questions
What did the University of Kentucky approve?
The university approved an accommodation excusing David Durman from personally using AI tools for his work, while allowing him to continue performing his job’s essential functions.
Does the decision mean employees can refuse all workplace AI?
No. It is an individual accommodation, not a general right to opt out of every AI system. The decision does not prevent coworkers or the university from using AI, and other requests would depend on their own circumstances.
Can a Humanist belief qualify for a religious accommodation?
Federal workplace law can cover some sincerely held moral or ethical beliefs that function with the strength of traditional religious beliefs. Whether a particular belief qualifies is assessed case by case; a personal preference alone is not automatically covered.
Is the Kentucky approval a legal precedent?
No. The university approved an employee accommodation without a lawsuit or court ruling. It does not establish a binding legal precedent for other employers.
What happens if Durman’s job changes?
The university may review the accommodation as his job changes, according to reporting about the approval letter. The public accounts do not specify a review date or how any future change would affect the exemption.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
