🔍 Read the full analysis: Amazon’s Tokenmaxxing Debate Is Really About What Success Means on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get business pricing on office and shipping supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
TL;DR
Amazon published engineering guidance on October 27 saying software engineers should be judged by customer and business outcomes, not token use or other AI activity counts. The memo still says adoption metrics can help identify trends, but warns that using them as targets can raise costs and complexity. Amazon’s differing fortunes with its Nova models and Anthropic investment give the debate wider significance, though the company’s third-quarter results were not yet available.
Amazon on October 27 published new guidance telling software engineers and managers to focus on customer and business outcomes, rather than token counts or other measures of AI activity. The memo responds to concerns about “tokenmaxxing” — using AI tools for unnecessary tasks to increase usage figures — and says those metrics can become counterproductive when treated as goals.
The guidance was published on Amazon’s own news site and introduces a revised role guideline for its software engineers, written by the company’s most senior engineers. It says long-term outcomes are the most relevant measures but can take time to assess. Teams have therefore used activity measures such as AI-tool adoption, tokens, code changes and reviews as proxies. The memo calls those measures “deeply flawed” when used as targets because they are disconnected from the results that matter and can increase costs and system complexity.
The memo does not call for abandoning AI or usage data. It says these input measures currently “correlate well” with important outputs, and that teams using AI more are delivering more, while teams that do not adopt it are “falling behind.” Its distinction is between using activity figures to spot patterns and using them to rank or reward employees. Managers are urged to examine both low and high adoption: understand why some teams are not finding AI useful, and check whether heavy users are producing better work.
The guidance also says that an engineer who finds current AI tools do not help with a particular task is providing useful information, not failing to meet an adoption expectation. Leaders are asked to use the tools in their own production work and describe where they helped and where they did not. The memo’s author, Terk Terkowitz, is a vice president and distinguished engineer in Amazon’s stores business.
Six months at Amazon
From token leaderboards to an outcomes memo
Amazon spent 2026 learning the same lesson twice: once with how its engineers use AI, once with its own AI models.
- May 2026Token leaderboards backfireFinancial Times (via The Decoder): staff give an internal agent tool pointless tasks to inflate token counts. Reported, anonymous sources.
- Late May 2026KiroRank “deprecated”Amazon spokesperson to Business Insider. SVP Dave Treadwell: “Please don’t use AI just for the sake of using AI.”
- 24 Jul 2026San Francisco AGI Lab site closesConfirmed by Amazon to GeekWire. Frontier model research continues under Pieter Abbeel.
- 28 Jul 2026Most flagship Nova models wound downBusiness Insider, people familiar: Premier, Omni, Reel, Canvas to “keep the lights on”. Amazon: models “remain one of the most important things we’re working on”.
- 14 / 30 Sep 2026Nova Sonic v1, Nova Reel, Nova Canvas reach end of lifeAWS Bedrock model lifecycle page. Requests to them now fail.
- 26 Oct 2026Anthropic files its S-1Amazon notes: $6.2 billion principal, 12% ownership cap that Amazon can waive. Anthropic commits at least $110 billion to Amazon through April 2036.
- 27 Oct 2026The memo: outcomes, not tokenmaxxingUsage and throughput metrics are “deeply flawed” as targets. “Tokenmaxxing is at odds with frugality.”
- 29 Oct 2026Amazon’s third-quarter resultsAnnounced by Amazon. Not yet published when this article went live.
Sources: Amazon engineering memo (27 Oct 2026); Business Insider (29 May and 28 Jul 2026); GeekWire (24 Jul 2026); The Decoder (12 May 2026, summarising the Financial Times); AWS Bedrock model lifecycle (read 28 Oct 2026); Anthropic S-1 (26 Oct 2026).
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
Why Amazon Is Changing the Scorecard
The memo addresses a measurement problem facing companies adopting generative AI: activity is easier to count than value. Token consumption and tool usage can show whether employees are trying a system, but they do not establish that the system improved a product, saved time or helped customers. If workers are rewarded for increasing activity, they may generate more usage without better outcomes.
For Amazon, the issue is tied to its leadership principle of frugality. The memo says “tokenmaxxing is at odds with frugality” and that measuring lines of code conflicts with “invent and simplify.” That makes the guidance more than a warning about one internal leaderboard: it sets expectations for how engineering leaders should interpret AI adoption across teams. It also leaves room for the company to use adoption data as a diagnostic, rather than treating it as proof of performance.
The question matters beyond Amazon because companies are under pressure to show returns from AI spending. The memo offers no financial results for those tools, but it does set out a standard for judging them: what changed in the work and for whom, rather than how much AI was used. Amazon is due to report third-quarter results on October 29, but those figures were not available when the guidance was published.
Popular right now

Roborock Qrevo S Pro Robot Vacuum and Mop with 18,500 Pa Suction

Samsung 85-Inch M80H Series 4K Mini LED Smart TV (2026)

Sony BRAVIA 5 85-Inch Mini LED 4K HDR Smart Google TV (K-85XR50)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Internal Rankings to Formal Guidance
The memo follows reports of internal efforts to track employee AI activity. In May, the Financial Times reported that some Amazon staff assigned unnecessary tasks to an internal agent tool called MeshClaw to raise their token counts. The report also described a weekly AI-use target and internal leaderboards. Those details came from reported accounts, including anonymous employee comments, and should not be treated as independently confirmed by the memo.
Amazon did confirm to Business Insider at the end of May that a leaderboard called KiroRank had been “deprecated.” The company described it as an informal tracker created by a group of employees and said it was never intended to encourage AI use for its own sake. Senior vice president Dave Treadwell also told staff, “Please don’t use AI just for the sake of using AI.” The October guidance now places the broader principle in an official engineering role guideline.
The source material also connects the memo to Amazon’s wider AI strategy, but the available evidence differs across its bets. Business Insider reported in July that most flagship Nova models had been moved to “keep the lights on.” Amazon’s lifecycle information lists Nova Canvas, Nova Reel and the first Nova Sonic as retired. By contrast, Amazon’s June 30 filing valued its Anthropic holdings at about $190 billion, after an investment described in the source material as about $18 billion. These figures are historical valuations, not a guarantee of future returns, and the source does not establish that they are directly comparable measures of the two strategies’ performance.
““Tokenmaxxing is at odds with frugality.””
— Amazon engineering memo
What the Memo Does Not Measure
The guidance does not provide a quantified estimate of whether AI use has improved productivity, reduced costs or improved customer outcomes across Amazon. It says adoption measures currently correlate with outcomes, but the memo does not supply the underlying data, define the size of that relationship or show how results vary by team or task. The reported Nova and Anthropic figures also do not, on their own, establish the long-term success of either strategy.
It is also unclear how Amazon will apply the guidance in performance reviews or how often teams will assess the outcomes. The memo argues against activity targets but does not set out a replacement company-wide scoring system. Reports about employees inflating usage through unnecessary tasks were attributed to sources in earlier coverage; Amazon’s published memo addresses the incentive risk but does not confirm every reported incident.
Amazon’s Results Are Due October 29
Amazon’s next scheduled public milestone is its third-quarter earnings report on October 29, two days after the memo’s publication. The report may provide a broader view of the company’s financial position, but the source material does not say whether Amazon will disclose specific returns from internal AI tools or from its Nova work.
For engineering teams, the memo points to a practical next step: managers are to examine why AI adoption is low or high, test tools in production work and record where they do and do not help. Whether that approach changes employee evaluations, internal tracking or investment decisions remains to be seen. The stated standard is clearer than the implementation: measure the result, not the amount of AI activity.
Key Questions
What does “tokenmaxxing” mean in this story?
It refers to using AI tools for unnecessary tasks to increase token counts or improve a usage ranking. Earlier reporting described such behavior among some Amazon employees; the company’s October memo warns against making token use a target.
Is Amazon telling engineers to stop using AI?
No. The memo says teams that adopt AI are delivering more, while cautioning that usage is not the same as impact. It calls for examining whether AI helps the work, not maximizing tool use.
What metrics does the memo criticize?
It names token use, AI-tool adoption, code changes and reviews as inputs that can be misleading when used as targets. The memo says they may still be useful for identifying patterns and currently correlate with important outputs.
What does Amazon’s Nova strategy have to do with the memo?
The source material uses Amazon’s reported Nova model reductions and its investment in Anthropic to illustrate different outcomes in the company’s AI strategy. Those developments provide context, but the memo does not claim that either investment directly caused the new guidance.
When will Amazon report its third-quarter results?
Amazon is scheduled to report third-quarter results on October 29, 2026. No results were available when the October 27 guidance was published.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
